Our Ice Cream is What Sets Us Apart
CREAMIEST in Florida
Yoder's Southern Creamery carefully selects each ingredient to make sure every flavor is rich and creamy. Once it hits your lips, you'll agree with us. There is no comparison.
Our ice cream is made the old-fashioned way, by real people, right here in Sarasota. The award-winning team at Yoder's Southern Creamery makes sure each tub of ice cream is made the right way.
Not Just Ice Cream
We also make old-fashioned, hand-spun milkshakes that are thick and full of flavor. Some of our unique recipes are generations old, and others are brand new creations. You'll love 'em!
Our Soft-Serve is Special
We also make a special version of soft-serve ice cream that allows us to churn some of our flavors into a soft swirl. We can churn many of our flavors into creamy soft serve. Come on in and try it!
Old Fashioned ShakesNostalgic Vanilla, Silky Smooth Chocolate, Grandpa's Root Beer
ClassicsSundae, Banana Split, Brownie Sundae, Go Big Or Go Home
Take It HomePint
Max's Frozen TreatsPeanut Butter Banana, Pumpkin Delight
Bowls & ConesKids/Small/Large
Waffle Cone or Bowl
Dairy Free Flavors
Churn Your FlavorChoose one of our churnable flavors
Ice Cream FlightChoose any 3 flavors
Take It Up A Notch
Toasted Marshmallow Meringue
ToppingsSprinkles, M&Ms, Gummy Bears, Oreos, Pecans, Almonds, Walnuts, Peanuts
Sauces & DrizzlesHot Fudge, Chocolate Sauce, Caramel Sauce, Butterscotch, Peanut Butter, Marshmallow
DrinksCoffee, Bottled Water, Soda
Try something fun by churning select flavors into a custom soft-serve creation.
Pick one of our carefully crafted milkshake recipes. Or, turn any flavor into a milkshake creation of your own.
Pro tip: Add our house-made, toasted marshmallow meringue to any order to turn it into a show stopper.